

All Blacks head coach Dave Rennie and captain Codie Taylor front the media after New Zealand's record 37-12 defeat to England at Twickenham on Sunday.
Photo/Photosport/Matt Impey
Two straight losses and a team struggling to hold on to the ball have left NZ with more questions than answers before their final game of the season.








There is no point pretending this is just a bad night at Twickenham.
The All Blacks have now lost two straight Nations Championship Tests, first to Wales 35-28 for the first time in 73 years and then 37-12 to England in New Zealand's heaviest defeat to a northern hemisphere side.
And the second loss was supposed to be the response.
Instead, it raised an uncomfortable question: what exactly is wrong with the All Blacks?
Head coach Dave Rennie has taken responsibility. “As head coach, you’re responsible for all the results. So I’m not going to hide from the fact that we weren’t good enough tonight, and I’m a big part of that.”
That honesty is welcome. But New Zealand needs more than an explanation before they face England again next weekend.
The worrying part of Twickenham was not simply the score. It was how little the All Blacks looked like the team in control.
England had about 70 per cent of the ball and territory for much of the first half. New Zealand had only about 30 per cent possession and territory and turned the ball over twice as often.
Rennie admitted the side were “miles off”. That is a serious problem for a team that have spent much of the year trying to build consistency.

The All Blacks gather after their 37-12 loss to England, their second straight defeat in the Nations Championship. Photo/Photosport/Matt Impey
The first issue is possession. You cannot expect to beat England or any top Test side if you keep handing the ball back.
Captain Codie Taylor put it plainly: “It was just a bit of a vicious cycle for us tonight. We make no excuses. We’ll own it. We just weren’t good enough out there.”
Then there was the set piece. The All Blacks lost their first two lineouts after half-time and struggled to build any rhythm from their own ball.
England's forwards were more aggressive especially at the breakdown and New Zealand spent too much of the match defending.

A dejected All Blacks team reflect after England's record 37-12 win at Twickenham. Photo/Photosport/Matt Impey
The numbers tell the story: England made 173 carries to New Zealand's 107 and ran 578 metres to the All Blacks' 313m.
New Zealand made 224 tackles. England made 117. That is not simply a difference in effort. It is a sign of where the game was being played.
Rennie said New Zealand had prepared for England's attacking style, particularly with Fin Smith at first five-eighth. “Everything that they delivered we expected but we didn’t deal with it well enough.”
That may be the biggest concern of all. The All Blacks knew what was coming. They still could not stop it.

Wallace Sititi takes on the England defence as Peter Lakai looks on. Photo/Photosport/Matt Impey
The wider context makes this harder to ignore. This is a team coming off a long season that included four Tests against South Africa, two against Australia and now a demanding northern tour.
There is an argument that fatigue is catching up with them. There is also an argument that the squad is still trying to find the right combinations and that some players have been asked to carry too much responsibility.
But those explanations can only go so far. England were sharper, more physical and more comfortable with the ball.
And as international outlets pointed out after the match, there were periods when England looked more like the All Blacks of old than New Zealand did.
The Guardian questioned whether the All Blacks looked like they were enjoying their rugby.
Planet Rugby described England's performance as a “statement” and said the team were playing with a swagger and confidence not seen from the Red and Whites for some time.

Leicester Fainga’anuku is brought down by the England defence after coming off the bench for the All Blacks. Photo/Photosport/Matt Impey
RugbyPass went further, saying the All Blacks looked like a “tired team with the weight of the world on their shoulders”.
That should sting. The All Blacks have spent generations being the team other nations measure themselves against.
Now England have beaten them twice in 12 months and Wales have just produced their first win over New Zealand in 73 years.
That does not mean the All Blacks are no longer a great rugby nation. It does mean the rest of the rugby world is no longer automatically afraid of them.
The slide is showing up in the rankings too. While World Rugby has yet to update its rankings, Planet Rugby has released its table showing New Zealand dropping to fifth with England moving above them into fourth after the Twickenham win. World champions South Africa remain top while Ireland have climbed to second place.

England captain Maro Itoje celebrates after leading his side to a second straight win over the All Blacks in 12 months. Photo/allblacks.com/file
Ethan de Groot: One of the better All Blacks on the night. He scored New Zealand's first try and worked hard in defence.
Fletcher Newell: Solid at scrum time and one of the more reliable forwards on a difficult night.
Fabian Holland: Worked hard on both sides of the ball and made an important contribution to Beauden Barrett's try.
Peter Lakai: Kept working at the breakdown and finished with a strong defensive effort.
Wallace Sititi: Put in a huge defensive shift but was outplayed by England's Ben Earl.

From left: halfback Cam Roigard, prop Fletcher Newell and captain Codie Taylor watch from the All Blacks bench during the defeat to England. Photo/Photosport/Matt Impey
Beauden Barrett: Quiet early but produced the All Blacks' best attacking moment with his 150th-Test try.
Cam Roigard: Struggled to influence the game and missed a key tackle on Earl.
Josh Moorby: Was barely able to get into the contest.
Rieko Ioane: Had limited impact and dropped a late high ball.
The replacements did little to change the momentum. Asafo Aumua and George Bower were among those who struggled after coming on.

The All Blacks perform the haka before their Nations Championship Test against England at Twickenham. Photo/Photosport/Matt Impey
First, the All Blacks need to stop trying to win the next game with emotion.
They need control. That means keeping the ball, winning their own set piece, making better decisions in their own half and defending as a connected unit instead of shooting out and leaving gaps.
They also need to decide what kind of team they want to be. England showed that a side can play with power while still moving the ball quickly and taking risks.
New Zealand looked reactive. Rennie says there is no question about the quality of his players or coaches.
“It’s a really proud group. We’re all incredibly disappointed, so we’ll want to make amends for that. I think getting the guys back up for one last crack won’t be difficult.”
That may be true. But the next challenge is not just about getting angry enough to win. It is fixing the things that England exposed. Because next weekend, the All Blacks get another chance against the same opponents. And this time, there can be no excuse about not knowing what is coming.

All Blacks lock Fabian Holland is stopped by the England defence during New Zealand's 37-12 defeat at Twickenham. Photo/Photosport/Matt Impey
The All Blacks vs England will be played on Sunday, 29 November at Twickenham at 5.40am (NZ time).
In other results this weekend, Scotland thrashed Japan 67-5, while Ireland edged South Africa 20-17 and Fiji beat Italy 21-16. France also beat Argentina 45-17 while Australia held off Wales 29-26. The results set up next weekend's play-offs with England facing New Zealand for third place, Ireland taking on Australia for fourth and Scotland playing Argentina for fifth and South Africa meeting France for the title.
In the second tier Nations Cup matches this weekend: Romania 27-26 Romania, Hong Kong China 19-55 Tonga, Georgia 38-10 USA, Spain 22-90 Sāmoa, Zimbabwe 29-34 Chile while the Portugal-Uruguay match was cancelled due to a waterlogged pitch.
The All Blacks vs England will be played on Sunday, 29 November at Twickenham at 5.40am (NZ time). For more details, visit world.rugby.
All Blacks: Ethan de Groot, Codie Taylor (captain), Fletcher Newell, Scott Barrett, Fabian Holland, Tupou Vaa’i, Peter Lakai, Wallace Sititi, Cam Roigard, Damian McKenzie, Josh Moorby, Jordie Barrett, Anton Lienert-Brown, Will Jordan, Beauden Barrett. Reserves: Asafo Aumua, George Bower, Pasilio Tosi, Anton Segner, Leicester Fainga’anuku, Cortez Ratima, Richie Mo’unga, Rieko Ioane.
England: Fin Baxter, Jamie George, Joe Heyes, Maro Itoje (captain), Alex Coles, Ollie Chessum (vice captain), Ben Curry, Ben Earl, Jack van Poortvliet, Fin Smith, Will Joseph, Seb Atkinson, Henry Slade, Tommy Freeman, George Furbank. Reserves: Luke Cowan-Dickie, Ellis Genge (vice captain), Will Stuart, George Martin, Greg Fisilau, Henry Pollock, Ben Spencer, Marcus Smith.