531 PI
Niu FM
PMN News

Delegates from the pacific including, far left Terito Story and far right Zoe Hoff, are part of Pacific countries advocacy for climate change at COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye.

Photo/Facebook/SPREP

Environment

From Paris hope to COP31 doubts: New Zealand MPs split on climate change talks

As COP31 enters its final week of negotiations, a former diplomat and an MP who was in Paris for the 2015 climate deal offer very different views on whether the talks can still deliver.

A decade after the Paris climate deal raised hopes of a global turning point, New Zealand MPs are divided over whether the annual climate talks are still delivering what the Pacific needs.

COP31 has reached its halfway point in Antalya, Türkiye, with negotiators now under pressure to find common ground before the talks close on 20 November.

New Labour MP and former diplomat, George Hampton, says the fact countries are still talking matters.

"You're talking to the wrong person to say anything's a talk fest, right? I was a diplomat for New Zealand for 13 years," Hampton told William Terite on Pacific Mornings.

"You walk into those corridors talking, but you know that that talking matters."

The newly elected MP for Christchurch Central says small countries cannot afford to stay quiet on issues such as climate change.

Watch George Hampton's full interview below.

"Unless little countries like ours say what should happen and act on that principle, then others won't follow. And we do have a strong voice that others listen for."

He says New Zealand should use that voice alongside its Pacific neighbours.

"Hopefully alongside our Pacific Island brothers and sisters to ensure that their voices are heard, because they're an incredibly relevant part of the conversation."

far right, Prime Minister of Niue, Dalton Tagelagi and his delegation at COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye. Photo/Facebok/SPREP

He says the stakes go well beyond politics.

"The life of my three-year-old will change fundamentally from the place and the times that we grew up in, unless we act more rapidly. And even little old New Zealand can do it."

But Green MP Teanau Tuiono has a much harder view of what the climate talks have achieved.

Tuiono lived in Paris for two years and returned for the 2015 climate talks that produced the Paris Agreement.

A decade later, he says the optimism he felt then has largely disappeared.

"We were all full of hope. I think I wanted it to be a stronger deal back then. But we got what we got," he tells Terite.

Listen to Teanau Tuiono's full interview below.

"We were hopeful that it was going to be enough, but it hasn't been. So it's been sad and depressing since then, to be honest."

Tuiono says he is “not always hopeful” when COP comes around and wants New Zealand to start talking climate change more seriously.

"Our relations in the Pacific are on the front lines of climate change."

The debate comes as Aotearoa’s political parties remain divided over the Paris Agreement.

NZ First has said the agreement should be "put out to pasture" while ACT has called for New Zealand to withdraw from it and has rejected the country's net-zero target.

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has said National secured agreement from ACT and NZ First to stay in the Paris pact when the government was formed in 2023.

Delegates at the Moana Blue Pacific Pavilion at COP31, Antalya, Türkiye. Photo/Facebook/SPREP

Climate Change Minister Simon Watts has described continued participation as "crucial".

With the government now in caretaker mode, New Zealand's Climate Change Ambassador Stuart Calman has been taking part in ministerial meetings in Antalya.

Australia's Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen is serving as President of Negotiations at COP31.

Pacific leaders remain focused on what countries can deliver through the talks. Palau's President and Pacific Islands Forum Chair Surangel Whipps Jr says the region has arrived in Antalya with a clear mandate from Forum leaders.

Fiji's Permanent Secretary for Environment and Climate Change, Dr Sivendra Michael, says the 1.5C target remains central to the Pacific's position. "For the Pacific, 1.5 to stay alive is not a slogan, it is our lifeline."

Delegates from Fiji, the Pacific and Africa, show the 1.5 symbol, pushing for climate temperature change at COP31, Antalya Türkiye. Photo/Facebook/SPREP

But with the talks now entering their final days, the focus is shifting from speeches to negotiations.

UN Climate Change Executive Secretary Simon Stiell has warned there will be "no collective success without compromise from every Party".

Hampton says that process is still worth engaging in. For Tuiono, the experience of the past decade has made optimism much harder to sustain.

COP31 ends on Friday.